ProcatalepsisProcatalepsis — illustrated emblem for the Mr. B Quotes glossary, category Rhetoric & Figures of Speech“PRHETORIC & FIGURES OF SPEECH
Rhetoric & Figures of Speech

Procatalepsis

Anticipating an objection in your own argument and answering it before it can be raised.

Procatalepsis (Greek προκατάληψις, 'anticipation') is the figure in which a speaker or writer raises a probable objection to their own argument and answers it before the audience can voice it. 'Some will say that this reform is too expensive; but the cost of doing nothing is greater' is a compact modern example.

The device has two great virtues. It disarms critics by showing that the speaker has already thought of their objection; and it lets the speaker frame the objection in the most easily answered form, which is a small but genuine rhetorical advantage. Any good persuasive essay uses procatalepsis at least once — usually in the paragraph before the conclusion.

Aristotle discusses the technique in the Rhetoric under the general topic of dealing with opposing arguments. It is close cousin to hypophora (asking a question in order to answer it) and to prolepsis (the general anticipation of anything future), but procatalepsis is specifically about objections.

Common mistake: caricaturing the objection so obviously that the reader sees the trick and stops trusting the writer. The strongest procatalepsis takes the strongest form of the counter-argument and answers it fairly. The reader who thinks 'yes, that is exactly what I would have said' is a reader now inclined to trust what the writer says next.

Example
“It will be objected that this is Utopian. I answer: the objection is old, and every real reform has met it.”
— Generic reformist argument, in the Aristotelian shape · The objection is named clearly and then answered directly — the two-step of procatalepsis.
Related terms

Keep reading the glossary